There’s something about a seasonal beverage you only get once a year that makes a gathering feel extra festive. Eggnog is one of those special treats forever associated with jovial times around a Christmas tree. When serving loved ones this season, there’s no need to offer several specialty beverages; instead, opt for the basics of wine and beer, and then choose one cocktail that has the holidays written all over it. Furthermore, choosing a specialty drink that doesn’t take much prep allows you to be present without having to fuss with concocting beverages that feel like they require bartending experience. Enter: the Halfway Homemade Bourbon Cream Eggnog recipe.

Full Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. This means we may earn a commission (at no cost to you!) should you choose to make a purchase using our links. It’s okay – we love these products, and hope you will too!!
Halfway Homemade Spiced Bourbon Cream Egg Nog

When it comes to holiday gatherings, there’s no more quintessential of a beverage than eggnog. While Shannon might personally pass on this cocktail offering, Jenna is always ready for a cup to ring in the Christmas season. However, who has the time to create this beverage from scratch?! If you also enjoy a cup of this traditional holiday offering but are short on time, then this easy, halfway homemade recipe is for you! With just three ingredients, create a simple, enjoyable cocktail perfect for sharing with loved ones this holiday season.
The Secret to Making to Making This Recipe
While there’s a variety of liquors that can be added to eggnog (namely brandy, bourbon or rum), we like to go with an option that makes a creamy drink even creamier and smoother: bourbon cream. This cream and bourbon combination is also a staple to have on hand at any home bar, especially during the winter months. In addition to mixing with eggnog, this bar staple is also ideal on the rocks or added to coffee.

What You Need to Make
The Ingredients
Halfway Homemade Spiced Bourbon Cream Eggnog
The Decorative Serveware + Essential Barware
Allow yourself to be present when hosting guests by having the tools you need at your finger tips. When serving this Halfway Homemade Spiced Bourbon Cream Eggnog, we recommend serving on a large charcuterie or cheese board for a cohesive aesthetic. Furthermore, having an essentials barware set allows you to have any component you might need when mixing up cocktails. Check out our favorites to get inspired!
How to Prepare This Recipe in 3 Easy Steps
When we say this recipe is easy, we mean it! Make this simple cocktail in minutes, and then serve to loved ones as you cozy up around the tree for deep conversations and well-deserved belly laughs.
To begin, combine one part bourbon cream and four parts store-bought egg nog, and stir gently. Next, sprinkle cinnamon on top, to taste. Finally, you can add a cinnamon stick to your beverage if you’d like an added festive detail!
That’s it! We hope the simplicity of this recipe gifts you the ability to be present and at peace when inviting people in this season. If you need more holiday inspo, scroll down for our Nana’s complete Christmas Eve recipe!
Halfway Homemade Spiced Bourbon Cream Eggnog
Ingredients
- 1 part bourbon cream (We recommend Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cream)
- 4 parts store-bought egg nog
- 1/2 tsp cinnamon, to sprinkle on top
- cinnamon sticks, optional
Instructions
- Combine 1 part bourbon cream and 4 parts store-bought egg nog, and stir gently.
- Sprinkle cinnamon on top.
- For added character, place one cinnamon stick in cocktail.
Complete Your Holiday Menu

Nana’s Aglio e Olio

Nana’s Mussels with Red Sauce

Aunt Tricia’s Shrimp Scampi
Trees are more important today than ever before. More than 10,000 products are reportedly made from trees. Through chemistry, the humble woodpile is yielding chemicals, plastics and fabrics that were beyond comprehension when an axe first felled a Texas tree.

Christmas Eve Seared Scallops

Leave a Reply